Publish the Numbers: Why the MoJ Is Fighting to Keep Conviction Data Secret

Publish the Numbers: Why the MoJ Is Fighting to Keep Conviction Data Secret

The Information Commissioner ordered the Ministry of Justice to publish conviction figures broken down by nationality. The Ministry of Justice has appealed.

That is the story, and you do not need a view on immigration to find it troubling. There is only one thing worth saying about a government fighting to keep a spreadsheet from the public, and it is this: publish it.

If you would rather have the numbers than be managed, you are in the right place.

What actually happened

A Freedom of Information request asked for conviction figures broken down by nationality and offence. The Ministry of Justice refused. The Information Commissioner's Office looked at the refusal and ordered disclosure. The Ministry has since challenged that decision, as Brussels Signal reported in July and GB News has also covered.

The information requested covers convictions between 2018 and 2024, broken down by serious offence categories.

We want to be careful here, because plenty of people online are not. Nobody outside the Ministry knows what those figures show. Not us, not the campaigners demanding release, not the accounts insisting they already know what is being hidden. Unpublished data is unpublished. Anyone telling you what is in it is guessing.

That is precisely the argument for releasing it.

The case for publishing, whatever it says

Run through the possibilities honestly.

If the figures show nothing remarkable, publish them, and a whole category of online claim collapses overnight. That is a good outcome for the government and it costs nothing.

If the figures show meaningful differences between nationalities, publish them, because the public is entitled to know what is true about the country it lives in.

And if the figures need serious context to be understood, which they almost certainly do, because raw conviction counts by nationality tell you nothing without age profile, sex, population size, length of residence and socioeconomic circumstances, then publish the context alongside them. Publish the methodology. Publish the caveats. Publish the warnings about what the numbers cannot support.

What you do not do is withhold the lot and expect people to take your word for it. Hiding information does not defeat misinformation. Better information defeats misinformation, and there is no third option.

Every month those figures stay unpublished, the vacuum gets filled by somebody with worse data and stronger motives. The Ministry's appeal is not preventing a conversation about migrants and crime. It is guaranteeing that the conversation happens without any facts in it.

MEGA Cap

Being trusted with the facts and being trusted to hold an opinion turn out to be the same argument. No oversized logo, no fuss, no apology. If that is where you land, this is the one.

Get mine · £32.99

Two other things happening in the same week

This is not an isolated argument, and the pattern is worth seeing whole.

In the Commons, an exchange on the asylum system took a wider turn when Jeremy Corbyn asked whether ministers had considered why there are so many refugees globally, putting the figure at around 70 million people without a home, and whether Britain should be part of an international effort rather than putting up barriers.

The shadow minister replying made two arguments. That people crossing the Channel are leaving France, which is a safe country, and are therefore not fleeing immediate danger. And that displaced people are generally better helped close to their country of origin than transported en masse to the West.

Both of those are serious positions and they deserve to be argued rather than shouted down. Acknowledging that suffering exists on that scale does not settle what any single country's obligation is. Those are two different questions and collapsing them is how this debate stops being a debate.

Meanwhile Reform UK set out a plan to bar foreign nationals from most benefits, including EU citizens with settled status. Policy chief Zia Yusuf put the saving from restricting universal credit to British citizens at £6.4 billion this year, rising to £10 billion by the end of the decade, according to the BBC.

The objections are real and they came from the right as much as anywhere. Kemi Badenoch called it a bad idea, pointing out that "we spent a lot of time negotiating those rights, not just for EU citizens in this country, but British citizens in other countries." Labour's chair Anna Turley warned it risked a trade war with Europe. Rights for settled EU citizens sit inside the withdrawal agreement, so this could not be done with a signature. It would mean reopening negotiations with Brussels, and British citizens living in the EU would be in the frame.

That does not make the underlying question illegitimate. What should citizenship actually be worth, and should someone who is not a citizen have identical access to the welfare state? People will answer that differently and both answers are respectable. But anyone proposing the change owes the public an honest account of what it would cost as well as what it would save.

What happens next

The appeal is the thing to watch. If it succeeds, the data stays unpublished and the argument continues in the dark. If it fails, we all get to find out what is actually in it, and some people on every side of this are going to be surprised.

Also worth watching: whether any minister is willing to say plainly why the Ministry is fighting the release, rather than leaving it to a legal process nobody is reporting.

Frequently asked questions

What data is the Ministry of Justice refusing to publish?

Conviction figures broken down by nationality and offence category, covering 2018 to 2024, requested under the Freedom of Information Act.

Who ordered it to be published?

The Information Commissioner's Office, the UK's independent regulator for information rights, which ordered disclosure after the Ministry initially refused the request.

Does this data prove anything about migrant crime?

No, because it has not been published. Nobody outside government knows what it contains. That is the reason to release it, not a reason to speculate about it.

Can Reform UK actually stop EU citizens claiming benefits?

Not straightforwardly. Rights for EU citizens with settled status derive from the UK's withdrawal agreement with the EU, so changing them would require reopening that agreement, with implications for British citizens living in EU countries.

Where we land

You can hold any view you like about immigration and still want the numbers published. That is not a partisan position, it is the minimum condition for having an argument worth having.

Give people the data. Give them the methodology and the caveats too. Then trust them to reach their own conclusions, which is what a country does with adults.

Nothing here is sponsored and no advertiser gets a say in which stories we cover or how bluntly we cover them. The shop is what keeps it that way. If this was worth your ten minutes, that is the most direct way to keep it coming.

Send me one · MEGA Cap

Commentary from The Englishman. Written from the sources linked above and from Andy The Gabby Cabby’s video of 2026-08-18. We sell clothing, and we say so on every page rather than at the bottom of one.