A clip from the Commons has been going round again this week. A Conservative frontbencher asks why the government is scrapping the cap on unfair dismissal compensation. The minister answering for the government replies by asking what he has got against protecting people from unfair dismissal.
Watch it twice. Those are not the same question, and the swap is the whole trick.
If you have ever asked a straight question at work and been answered a different one, you are our sort of reader.
What is actually being changed
Until now, compensation for ordinary unfair dismissal has been limited to the lower of 52 weeks' gross pay or £118,223. That ceiling has been part of employment law for years.
The Employment Rights Act 2025 removes it. From January 2027 there will be no statutory maximum on the compensatory award, as employment lawyers at Farrer & Co have set out for employers preparing for the change.
So the question Andrew Griffith put was narrow and specific. Why remove the financial ceiling altogether, and what has been considered about what that means for hiring, investment and the willingness of a small firm to take somebody on?
That is a question about liability. It is answerable. It was not answered.
The substitution
What came back was an argument about whether workers deserve protection from being sacked unfairly.
Nobody in that chamber was arguing they do not. That is the point. You can support unfair dismissal protection and still ask whether compensation for it should have no upper limit. Those two positions sit together perfectly comfortably. Treating the second as an attack on the first is not a rebuttal, it is a way of not having the conversation.
Griffith kept pulling it back. His line was that the whole reason the Bill had come back to the Commons was the government's desire to remove a cap of £118,000, which in his words would "only ever benefit those who are the better off". He also claimed 15 per cent of young people are unemployed, and said his side wanted to get Britain working again. That is his figure and his framing, and voters can weigh it.
The reply widened again, to insecure work, low pay and people not knowing what hours they will get. All real things. None of them an answer about a ceiling.
Where the government has a genuinely strong card
We are not going to pretend one side has all of this.
The government's best argument is a number, and it is a good one. The median unfair dismissal compensatory award in 2023/24 was £6,746. Only around six per cent of awards exceeded £50,000. Almost nobody was getting anywhere near the £118,223 ceiling in the first place.
That matters, because it undercuts the idea that removing the cap means every employer suddenly faces enormous payouts. Tribunals do not hand out maximums. Claimants still have to prove their losses.
But it cuts both ways, and this is the part that rarely gets said. If hardly anybody reaches the cap, why was abolishing it worth becoming one of the final sticking points of the entire Bill? A change that affects almost no cases does not usually get fought over that hard. Either it matters more than the median suggests, or it was symbolic. Both answers are interesting, and neither was given.
The bit that got much less attention
Ministers said discussions had taken place with business representatives and trade unions. Six organisations then put out a joint statement that told a more precise story.
The British Chambers of Commerce, the CBI, the Federation of Small Businesses, the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development, the Recruitment and Employment Confederation and Small Business Britain set out their position on 15 December 2025. They confirmed they had agreed a six-month qualifying period and had agreed to removing the 52-week cap. On the cash cap, they said something rather different: "we have not been able to reach a compromise that satisfies both the unions' request for removal of the cash cap and our position of retaining it while raising the overall limit."
Read plainly, that is business groups saying they agreed to one thing and not the other, while the impression being given was broader agreement. Parliament was entitled to ask exactly what had been settled with whom.
Here is what makes this exchange worth your time, and it has nothing to do with employment law. A specific question was asked, and the answer given was to a different, easier question that nobody had raised. It works because the substituted question sounds unarguable. Who could be against protecting workers? And while you are busy agreeing with that, the thing actually being decided sails past unexamined.
You have sat through that manoeuvre in a meeting. You have watched it on the news. Recognising it is most of the defence against it.
The people who actually build things in this country are rarely the loudest in the room, and they are almost never the ones getting a straight answer. This is the quiet one in our range, made for exactly that person.
What happens next
The Act is law. The cap disappears in January 2027, and only then does anyone get real evidence about who was right.
The things to watch are whether tribunal awards actually shift once the ceiling goes, whether small employers change hiring behaviour in advance of the date, and whether the government publishes any assessment of the change it declined to make while the Bill was going through.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cap on unfair dismissal compensation?
Compensation for ordinary unfair dismissal has been limited to the lower of 52 weeks' gross pay or £118,223. It applies to the compensatory award and is separate from the basic award.
When is the unfair dismissal cap being removed?
The Employment Rights Act 2025 removes it with effect from January 2027.
Does removing the cap mean bigger payouts?
Not automatically. Claimants still have to establish their actual losses, and the median award in 2023/24 was £6,746. Removing a ceiling changes what is possible in the largest cases, not what is typical.
Did business groups agree to scrapping the cap?
Partly. In a joint statement on 15 December 2025, six business organisations confirmed they had agreed a six-month qualifying period and the removal of the 52-week cap, but said no compromise had been reached between the unions' position of removing the cash cap and their own of retaining it while raising the limit.
Where we land
There is a real argument here about risk, hiring and how much a mistake should cost an employer, and reasonable people land in different places on it.
What there is not is an excuse for answering a question about a compensation ceiling with a question about whether you like workers. Ask the actual question. Get the actual answer. That is not a lot to want.
Nothing here is sponsored and no advertiser gets a say in which stories we cover or how bluntly we cover them. The shop is what keeps it that way. If this was worth your ten minutes, that is the most direct way to keep it coming.
Commentary from The Englishman. Written from the sources linked above and from Andy The Gabby Cabby’s video of 2026-08-20. We sell clothing, and we say so on every page rather than at the bottom of one.